Impala’s ‘jaw-jaw’ strategy in Zim

With the final countdown underway on the Zimbabwe indigenisation saga, let’s take a hard look at what’s at stake come November 15 when Zimplats is due to submit its final proposal to government.

If it all goes pear-shaped the losers will include Impala Platinum (Implats) — which owns 87% of Zimplats — but also what’s left of the Zimbabwean economy, as well as a host of mining companies trying to get projects off the ground in the rest of Africa.

Other African countries will be watching the outcome closely and they will draw their own conclusions over what is possible if the Zimbabwe government gets away with its latest demands.

Those include reneging on contracts previously struck with Implats and grabbing 51% of the assets of all the mining companies operating in the country.

Zimbabwe’s politicians should realise they have as much to lose here as Implats.

A negative outcome would destroy the country’s last remaining chance of staging a worthwhile economic recovery based on the large-scale development of its platinum group metals (PGM) mining sector.

It would be the mining equivalent of the earlier disastrous farming land grab which transformed Zimbabwe from a bread basket into a basket case in a matter of years.

Zimbabwe hosts the second-largest known PGM resource in the world after South Africa.

What the past decade has shown through the operations of Zimplats and Mimosa (a 50/50 joint venture between Implats and Aquarius Platinum) is that this resource can be mined very profitably, even though it is lower grade than the South African deposits.

The Zimbabwe mining operations are mechanised, making them low-cost while the workforce is well-educated and highly motivated.

That makes the Zimbabweans far more productive than their South African counterparts.

Zimplats and Mimosa have consistently shown the highest percentage profit margins out of all Implats’ divisions for years, despite the economic and social meltdown that Zimbabwe has been through.

That’s why Implats wants to boost Zimplats to the point where it can produce one million ounces of platinum annually within 10 to 20 years, which would put Zimplats on a par with Implats’ current flagship Rustenburg mining complex.

To make that happen Implats has to build smelters along with base metal and precious metal refineries in Zimbabwe, as well as the necessary mining infrastructure.

That means massive skills and technology transfers to the country in addition to the obvious job creation opportunities, both directly on the mines and indirectly through the economic multiplier effect.

Building those refineries is also likely to help the development of junior platinum companies in Zimbabwe if Implats adopts the same business approach to toll refining that it has employed in South Africa.

But that’s not going to happen if the Zimbabwe government sticks to its 51% indigenisation equity demands.

Throughout all of process so far, Implats — and the other Zimbabwe platinum operators which include Anglo American Platinum’s Unki operation — have kept their public responses both low-key and surprisingly upbeat.

The reason for that only became widely apparent in September when Tapiwa Mashakada — the country’s Minister for Economic Planning and Investment Promotion — presented to the Africa Down Under conference in Australia.

He sounded a lot more conciliatory than the hard-line stance delivered by Saviour Kasukuwere — Zimbabwe’s Indigenisation and Empowerment minister — who had monopolised the headlines up to that point.

Mashakada criticised Kasukuwere for his actions saying he did not have the power to enforce his threats, only the Zimbabwe Cabinet could do that.

A platinum industry source confirms they have been subjected to this “good cop-bad cop” routine for years as Zimbabwe’s politicians have tried to get their way.

But the platinum miners could also put on a convincing “bad-cop” routine if they wanted to.
Consider, for example, the ground Implats gave back to the Zimbabwe government so as to secure title to its current mining rights.

That is apparently a huge sticking point in the latest negotiations. Never forget that Zanu PF previously opted for economic suicide over the land issue . . .

The Zimbabwe government passed that ground on to Russian and Chinese investors, but neither has done anything with the rights.

Why has there been no development of that ground? The answer is because the platinum business is a tough nut to crack and there are considerable financial and technical barriers to entry.

So, what if Implats decided to play “bad cop” from its side and threaten to mothball the Zimplats operation? Implats doesn’t even have to threaten — just let the word get out that they are thinking about doing it.

That should focus even the hardest-core Zanu PF political mindset on the realities of the situation, but it would be a dangerous strategy.

Never forget that Zanu PF previously opted for economic suicide over the land issue and business “brinkmanship” of this nature could rapidly lead to a situation where nobody will back off.

So it’s highly likely Implats will continue with its policy of “jaw-jaw” rather than “war-war” until it feels it has absolutely nothing to lose.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Article source:


Leave a Reply

Other News


    Veteran Zimbabwe Politician Urges ZANU-PF to Ditch Mugabe in 2012 Elections

    Veteran Zimbabwe Politician Urges ZANU-PF to Ditch Mugabe in 2012 Elections Nkala, in whose Highfield, Harare, home ZANU-PF was formed in 1963, charged that “cowboys, power seekers and fly-by-night politicians” have hijacked the party in pursuit of personal glory and financial gain Sandra Nyaira | Washington Veteran Zimbabwean politician and ZANU-PF founding member Enos Nkala has urged the party to drop President Robert Mugabe as its 2012 presidential candidate when it meets later this year for an annual conference, saying [...]

    Read more →

    Obama’s Zimbabwe Moment

    As the world focuses on events in the Arab world, and as dictators such as Muammar Gaddafi are overthrown, America’s first African-American president has a historic chance to deal with one of Africa’s most vicious despots — Robert Mugabe. Mugabe has imposed economic, financial, social and environmental ruin on his nation, and it is time to call an end to his reign of destruction. Since his election in 1980, Mugabe, now seventy-nine, has created a virtual “how-to” manual for national [...]

    Read more →

    Zimbabwe President, PM, Others Spend US$50 Million Traveling in September

    Zimbabwe President, PM, Others Spend US$50 Million Traveling in September Biti said he has no power to stop President Mugabe, Prime Minister Tsvangirai and other top officials from embarking on costly foreign trips, at times with large entourages receiving US$250 daily allowances Gibbs Dube Tatenda Gumbo | Washington Economist Eric Bloch says parliament is the only state arm that can rein in travel spending. Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Cabinet ministers ran up a travel bill [...]

    Read more →

    Zimbabwe Indigenization Minister Shrugs Off PM Tsvangirai’s Criticisms

    Zimbabwe Indigenization Minister Shrugs Off PM Tsvangirai’s Criticisms ‘regrettable” that his economic empowerment program has been seized upon by some political parties as an election issue, this in apparent response to comments by Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai that his MDCformation “totally opposes” the indigenization drive which he characterized as a Zanu-PF scheme. Addressing a news conference in Harare Tuesday, Indegenization Minister Saviour Kasukuwere accused un-named political parties of Taking the Indegenization process as a campaign tool ahead of Elections that [...]

    Read more →

    Whites ‘delayed’ MDC growth: Tsvangirai

    A PERCEPTION that the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) was a creation of disaffected white Zimbabweans “delayed the party’s growthâ€� and alienated it “within peer groups in Africa”, Morgan Tsvangirai says in a new book. Tsvangirai blames the “exaggerated transparencyâ€� of his white supporters for aiding Zanu PF “propagandaâ€� projecting the party as a front for powerful white interests. Following the party’s formation in 1999, Tsvangirai says “many whites, especially in rural Mashonaland, began to enquire about the role they [...]

    Read more →

    Zimbabwe: Deportations of Zimbabweans a Political Move

    “Mwana washe muranda kumwe” is an old Zimbabwean saying which means that when one is a foreigners they are a nobody in the eyes of the host country and this rings true today as thousands of Zimbabweans face deportation from South Africa back to Zimbabwe. The South African government has decided to lift a moratorium on deportations of undocumented Zimbabweans who did not apply for legal status through the Zimbabwe Documentation Process (ZDP). Zimbabweans queue to apply for work permits [...]

    Read more →

    Campbell quits as Zim selector

    Harare - Alistair Campbell resigned as Zimbabwe’s head selector on Tuesday to focus more on his work as a commentator, saying there was a conflict of interest in holding both roles. Zimbabwe Cricket (ZC) said the former captain had stepped down as a selector immediately but would stay on as chairman of the national body’s cricket committee. Campbell will be replaced by former Zimbabwe wicketkeeper Wayne James, ZC said in a statement. James joins another former international, Kevin Curran, and [...]

    Read more →

    Zimbabwe: Will Thomas Mapfumo Come Back?

    Published by the government of Zimbabwe Fred Zindi 18 October 2011 opinion For the past two years rumours about Dr Thomas Mapfumo’s homecoming have been widespread. Latest rumours are that Zimbabwean Chimurenga musician Thomas Mukanya Mapfumo is expected in Zimbabwe before the end of the year. However, this is all hearsay. I spoke to Mapfumo recently and he expressed his fears of coming back to Zimbabwe and he referred me to his then manager, Allan Katz who was also fearful [...]

    Read more →